LOGAN — After 36 1/2 years of serving ice cream, malts and memories to Cache Valley residents, Charlie’s Supreme Malts & Ice Cream is closing its doors on November 21, marking the end of an era for one of Logan’s best-known ice cream shops.
Located at 1219 N. Main St., the business has been more than a place to enjoy a scoop of ice cream. For generations of residents, it has been a gathering place where teenagers went on their first dates, families celebrated after Little League games and couples stopped for a treat after church services or concerts.
For Craig Earl and his wife Lorraine, the decision to close the shop brings mixed emotions after more than three decades of serving the community.
“I have mixed feelings about closing Charlie’s,” Earl said. “It’s sad, but it will relieve a lot of stress.”
The Earls opened the shop June 4, 1990, after purchasing and remodeling a building that had previously housed a business selling eyeglasses and later a video rental store.
“The building was originally built for a company that sold glasses, then it was a video rental place,” Earl said. “We bought it, remodeled it and put in the drive-thru and opened it on June 4, 1990.”
The name Charlie’s came from Earl’s middle name, which was also the name family members and high school friends used when referring to him.
By the time he opened the Logan location, Earl already had years of experience in the ice cream business. He earned a bachelor’s degree in food science from Utah State University in 1975 and began making ice cream products in 1979.
“I was working at a malt shop at 589 North Main in the Clock Tower Plaza,” he said. “I used to make Creamies there in the back. The front part was a cafe.”
The frozen treats were originally called Fudgies before Earl rebranded them as Creamies.
As the business grew, he moved operations to Hyde Park and established Heart to Heart Foods. He operated the company for about 10 years before opening Charlie’s.
Earl eventually sold Heart to Heart Foods in 2021 to Casper’s, which at the time was producing approximately 30 million Creamies annually.
While Heart to Heart Foods became known for its frozen treats, Charlie’s maintained its own identity, offering ice cream made from Earl’s original recipes.
“All of the ice cream at Charlie’s is my original recipe, and after closing the store, that ice cream will no longer be available,” Earl said. “When I retire, the recipe will retire with me.”
Over the years, the shop also became known for its employees. Many were high school and college students who worked behind the counter and became part of the Charlie’s experience.
“The girls at the counter at Charlie’s were at one time called ‘Charlie’s Angels,’” Earl said. “If you called them that today, no one would get it.”
The shop attracted customers following high school and Utah State University sporting events, along with families looking for a place to celebrate after a long summer day.
Earl said young athletes frequently stopped by with parents and coaches after Little League games. The shop also welcomed generations of couples and families who made visiting Charlie’s part of their traditions.
After spending nearly half his life making ice cream products, Earl said he believes it is simply time to step away.
“I hope we’ve made a lot of people happy over the years,” he said.
