CACHE COUNTY – During a scheduled Truth-in-Taxation hearing on Nov. 17, members of the Cache County Council found themselves obliged to swallow pointed criticism from some residents over their recently approved salary increases.
In the course of that public hearing, county residents Andrea Ellis of Hyde Park, Sam Hicken of Paradise, Hannah Mortensen of Providence and Craig Bailey of River Heights all focused their three-minute comments on the compensation levels for elected and executive county officials approved on Nov. 10.
In total, those pay hikes for county officials will raise county compensation expenses by nearly $260,000 in 2027, from the current $1,293,000 to $1,552,000, according to Amy Adams, the county director of Human Resources.
Despite those criticisms from local residents, the council members concluded the hearing by voting six-to-one to approve property tax increases of 3.62 percent for the county’s General and Health Funds (generating new revenue of $760,000); 35.27 percent for the county’s Assessing and Collecting Levy (producing $1.3 million in new revenue) and a 100 percent for fire protection and emergency medical services in the unincorporated portions of the county (generating $800,000 in new revenue).
Only outgoing council member JoAnn Bennett voted against those tax increases.
Seven residents appeared at the Nov. 17 public hearing to raise issues about the proposed budget for 2027, with more than half of them expressing concern about the salary increases approved a week earlier.
Craig Bailey wondered if the members of the council would have been so quick to approve the salary increase for themselves if that vote had happened prior to the Nov. 3 election rather than a week later.
As outlined in Ordinance 2026-36, the approved pay increase will raise council members’ salaries from $24,000 per year to $34,000 and hike the salary of Council Chair Sandi Goodlander from $30,000 to $40,000.
New salary increases varying from $57,000 for County Executive George Daines to $6,000 for the county attorney were also approved.
Both Bennett and Goodlander lost their council seats to opposing challengers during the Nov. 3 countywide balloting.
Hyde Park resident Andrea Ellis disputed Adams’ argument that the county needed to offer competitive salaries to attract qualified office holders in the future.
“People will take a pay cut to live here in Cache Valley,” she contended. “The valley itself is the draw; we shouldn’t need over-blown salaries.”
Sam Hicken raised the traditional issue that county office holders should be motivated by public service rather than compensation, especially focusing on what he called the excessive $57,000 pay raise approved for Daines in 2027.
“These should not be career positions,” he added, where elected officials benefit at the expense of taxpayers.
County library advocate Hannah Mortensen also took exception the compensation comparisons cited by Adams to justify the recently approved pay increases.
That study used Summit County as one of its points of comparison. The median income there is $138,000 a year and the average home value is $1.6 million, according to Mortensen, compared to the median Cache Valley income of $85,000.
The members of the Cache County Council are expected to approve a tentative $103 million budget for 2027 in December.
